19 Ben & Jerry’s Dairy-Free Ice Cream Flavors Ranked

It’s a wondrous and barely anxiety-inducing expertise to behold 19 totally different ice cream pints open earlier than you—all completely thawed and able to be sampled. This was the state of affairs I discovered myself in once I visited the Ben & Jerry’s headquarters throughout a uncommon, sunny summer season day in Burlington, VT. Together with different members of the media, I scooped and savored every taste to my raging dopamine delight.

Since that sugar-induced day, I’ve continued to take pleasure in a scoop of Ben & Jerry’s Non-Dairy on occasion with the intention to hone my humble but very robust opinion of every taste. Most individuals won’t ever be confronted with 19 totally different taste choices (the model solely carries one or two non-dairy varieties in its scoop outlets and retailers by no means carry the total line), however however, it helps to know what’s good, and what’s actually good. As a result of let’s be sincere, there aren’t any dangerous flavors right here. From simply advantageous to eat-the-whole-pint, listed below are all of the Ben & Jerry’s Non-Dairy flavors ranked from advantageous to finest. 

Chunks, swirls, and inventing cookie dough ice cream

Ben & Jerry’s is an iconic ice cream model for extra than simply its decades-long endurance. This model does issues otherwise, and due to that, it has many firsts to its identify. It launched its first scoop store in Burlington, VT in 1978 with eight dairy-based flavors—Oreo Mint, French Vanilla, Wild Blueberry, Mocha Walnut, Chocolate Fudge, Honey Espresso, and Honey Orange. 

Ben & Jerry’s

Not one of the authentic flavors have survived at the moment, however they stood out amongst different pints on the time for his or her daring style and sizable mix-ins. The chunks and swirls the model has develop into identified for had been a results of Ben’s impaired potential to odor and style. When Ben may really style it, they knew the flavour was pronounced sufficient. 

Ben & Jerry’s was additionally the primary model to commercially produce cookie dough ice cream. Following a buyer suggestion, the group devoted time to recipe growth and launched cookie dough ice cream pints in 1991. The thought of baked items and ice cream have clearly labored out for the model—you’ll see beneath {that a} important variety of flavors contain cookies, brownies, dough, or some mixture of all three. 

19 Non-dairy Ben & Jerry’s ice cream flavors, ranked

Ben & Jerry’s

19 Cherry Garcia

I’ve by no means actually understood the craze surrounding this cult taste. I’ve sampled each the dairy model (pre-vegan) and the non-dairy model, and whereas I used to be happy to notice that they style the identical, the flavour itself by no means actually excited my palate. If this chocolate-cherry mixture makes you do backflips, this pint could also be greater in your listing. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

18 Americone Dream

Sorry, Stephen Colbert, however this didn’t fairly hit the mark. Followers had been imploring Ben & Jerry’s for a dairy-free choice for years, and the model lastly churned it out. The flavour works in concept: a vanilla base swirled with a vegan caramel ribbon and dotted with chocolate-covered waffle cone items. Maybe my pattern was a dud, however the waffle cone items had been soggy and I discovered myself avoiding the chunks, slightly than looking for them out. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

17 Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

I welcome the controversy over this rating, as I do know this basic taste is a favourite amongst tens of millions. There’s a cause why the corporate launched its vegan cookie dough chunks, in any case. Though this ice cream is tasty, the product is simply shy of hitting that childhood nostalgia notice for me. Sure, Ben & Jerry’s does declare to be the primary to mass-produce Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, however others have run with the concept and made it higher. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

16 Lights! Caramel! Motion!

Developed in collaboration with movie director Ava DuVernay, this taste made its grocery retailer debut in early 2023. Made to DuVernay’s specs (plus some inventive liberties taken by Taste Gurus), this pint contains salted caramel swirls, graham cracker swirls, and chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough suspended in a vanilla ice cream base. Regardless of all these chunks and swirls, the flavors don’t seize you. It’s candy, and there’s loads of texture, however the depth of taste is missing. After a number of spoonfuls, I used to be content material to let my accomplice end the pint.
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

15Chocolate Fudge Brownie

As one of many first non-dairy Ben & Jerry’s flavors launched in 2016, this pint made my coronary heart pitter-patter with delight seven years in the past. Nonetheless, that was earlier than I noticed what these Taste Gurus (sure, that’s what they’re referred to as) can actually do. The Chocolate Fudge Brownie is a variety of … chocolate. Sure, it’s redundant, however once I pop open a pint, I count on a bit extra variation in taste. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

14 Oatmeal Dream Pie

As my palate has matured to its 30-year-old self, I’ve found that I immensely take pleasure in a balanced cinnamon-flavored ice cream. I used to be excited once I heard the information of this new taste, however then I noticed cinnamon is lacking from the ingredient deck. The result’s a bit missing—the marshmallow swirls and oatmeal cookie items want a bit extra taste dimension. That being stated, I’m curious to see how this taste would end up in a milkshake with a beneficiant sprint of cinnamon added. 
Discover it right here

Sarah McLaughlin/VegNews

13Karamel Sutra Core

The primary non-dairy taste in Ben & Jerry’s Core line, this pint options chocolate and caramel ice cream dotted with fudge chips and full of a gooey, caramel core. It’s completely advantageous, however Ben & Jerry’s chocolate base may use an improve. Maybe it wants extra cacao, maybe it simply will get in the best way of different tasting notes. Both means, you’ll discover a lot of the model’s chocolate flavors don’t rank as excessive for me. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

12The Tonight Dough

Impressed by the Jimmy Fallon-endorsed dairy model, this pint is created with a marbling of caramel and chocolate almond milk ice lotions ribboned with chocolate cookie swirls wrapped round gobs of chocolate chip cookie dough and peanut butter cookie dough. Did I lose you with that description? As a result of that’s what occurs to those flavors—they get misplaced. Whereas scrumptious on their very own, every part muddles the remaining. Jimmy, I’m sorry to say, however you may’t have all of it. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

11Increase! Chocolatta

One other pint throughout the Non-Dairy Core choice, this taste is Ben & Jerry’s first go at a vegan and gluten-free choice. It’s unbelievable for these with gluten sensitivities, however in full transparency, it tastes gluten-free. It’s the slight graininess of chocolate cookie chunks and inside chocolate cookie core that give it away. Additional, the blending of mocha and caramel ice lotions doesn’t work. It’s not dangerous—by no means—however that is Ben & Jerry’s, and I maintain them to impossibly excessive requirements. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

10 Peanut Butter Half Baked

The identify of this ice cream definitely doesn’t mirror the innovation behind it—the complexity of its parts is just not half-baked in any respect (sorry, dangerous pun). Peanut butter and chocolate ice lotions are marbled collectively and studded with fudge brownies and peanut butter cookie dough. If the Chocolate Fudge Brownie is simply too one-note, this may be only a smidge an excessive amount of. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

9Mint Chocolate Probability

Accessible in each non-dairy and dairy variations, Probability the Rapper made one factor very clear when he partnered with Ben & Jerry’s: the chunks should be huge. Given this path, the Taste Gurus got here up with a mint-flavored sunflower butter-based ice cream dotted with boulders of vegan brownies. It’s a stable mixture, however I do assume a number of different manufacturers have carried out mint higher (howdy, NadaoMoo! Mint Chip). 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

8Bananas Foster

This taste grows on you, even in case you don’t love bananas. It rounds out the trio of Non-Dairy Core pints, that includes a cinnamon-spiked banana ice cream, almond toffee items, and a luscious salted caramel core. Nobody will choose in case you eat the core first. When completely thawed, it’s almost not possible to cease consuming. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s 

7P.B. & Cookies

If you happen to’re a fan of Oreos dipped in peanut butter, you’ll want to do this taste. It had its run in scoop outlets and has since been retired to pint-only. I loved this vanilla ice cream swirled with chunky peanut butter and studded with chocolate sandwich cookies, but when hard-pressed, I barely desire Oreos slathered with peanut butter and dipped in cashew milk.
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

6Coconut Seven Layer Bar

Whereas Jerry knowledgeable us that he may by no means get by a pint of this taste, I assumed it was excellent. Identical to the dessert, there’s so much occurring right here, but it surely works. Coconut ice cream acts because the glue between the ample fudge chunks, walnuts, and streaks of graham cracker and caramel swirls. It’s a refreshing outlier to the dominant chocolate and cookie-based flavors. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

5 Colin Kaepernick’s Change the Whirled

The graham cracker swirls on this taste are the star of the present. Made with caramel-flavored ice cream, it additionally options chocolate cookie swirls and fudge chips. One of the best half? Parts of gross sales are donated to Colin Kaepernick’s Know Your Rights Camp to assist advance the well-being and liberation of Black and Brown communities. Word: it’s undoubtedly on the sweeter aspect, even for Ben & Jerry’s. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

4Mint Chocolate Cookie

Simply shy of my high three is that this marvelously minty sunflower butter-based pint. Comparatively easy by Ben & Jerry’s requirements, mint ice cream is dolloped with enormous chocolate sandwich cookies. Yep, that’s it, and it doesn’t want something extra.
Discover it right here 

Ben & Jerry’s

3“Milk” & Cookies

Assume cookies and cream, however exponentially superior in each conceivable means. Easy vanilla sunflower butter-based ice cream acts because the clean canvas for chocolate chip cookies, chocolate sandwich cookies, and chocolate cookie swirls. It’s primarily a sundae in a pint—simply add vegan whip and a cherry.  
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

2 Netflix & Chill’d

I’ve nagged on flavors that attempt to incorporate too many substances, but this over-the-top taste someway doesn’t exceed the “an excessive amount of” barrier and delivers on the last word indulgence. I’ll without end be enamored with this peanut butter ice cream that’s decked with fudge brownies and a salted pretzel swirl. How do they even create a swirl out of salted pretzels? My thoughts is blown, and my senses are overloaded with delight each time I deal with myself to this taste. Hat’s off to you, Ben and Jerry, for frequently pushing the boundaries of what vegan ice cream might be. 
Discover it right here

Ben & Jerry’s

1 Phish Meals

Like Cherry Garcia, I wasn’t a fan of this taste within the pre-vegan days. I held my pattern spoonful with low expectations, figuring out that I had no nostalgia for this selection and in addition figuring out that Ben & Jerry’s chocolate base wasn’t my favourite. I used to be so flawed. Phish Meals is the flavour to beat. The chocolate is wealthy, the fudge phish mouthwateringly decadent and tender, and the marshmallow swirl isn’t too candy. When it’s all put along with a ribbon of caramel, this taste is just enchanting. You’ll stand at your kitchen countertop, digging by the pint to carve out your excellent chunk, misplaced in your individual pleasurable world till out of the blue you notice half the carton is gone. It’s harmful, however in case you’re on the lookout for a candy escape, that is it.  
Discover it right here